Potential and Capabilities
While Comet is promising with Perplexity at the core, integration with email and calendar, plus the ability to actually take over and click around for you, Dia is what I am opening and using every day. It's tab management is just significantly better.
Browser Interaction
Comet can interact with open tabs, clean up and group tabs, similarly to Dia. That said, Comet allows you to actually talk with your browser via a voice assistant, and even navigate the pages your on at times, showing you a deeper layer of browser interaction that you don't get with Dia.
History & Memory
Right now Dia allows you to reference your history with @history, allowing it to go a bit deeper on personalization based on your prior searches and pages visited. Comet doesn't go too deep into history or memory as of now, bup Perplexity has said that they are diving more into memory in the future (which will make its way into Comet).
Dia Skills
Dia has skills that you can trigger with /skillname which are effectively pre-set prompting before a search is sent or chat is completed. They also have a marketplace where you can grab these skills (prompts) and modify them for your own usage. It's definitely a standout feature.
Monetization and Business Model
Perplexity knows how to make money and has way more resources, so I believe they'll actually have a sustainable business model (they already do). That means they'll be able to do more and figure out how to monetize the browser effectively.
Search Functionality
Perplexity is a search engine that's already good, and I use it alongside ChatGPT. Dia is mostly using an OpenAI wrapper (and Anthropic) for their search, so I'm just generally less bullish because I find myself missing both Perplexity and ChatGPT when using Dia, they just have less IP as a whole.
Overall Outlook
With all of that said, Perplexity is already a fantastic search engine. So taking that and building a browser around it makes a lot of sense. In-fact, it's getting me even more excited for OpenAI's upcoming browser as they are leading the charge when it comes to chat and search.
I'm unsure if just pure product and design quality can win in this space. Love how Dia looks and the team behind it is exceptional, just not totally sure if it's enough being more of a wrapper of these other AI tools at the core.