With both Motion and Asana, you're going to get core project management features like kanban boards and team project/task collaboration (unlike that of Motion vs Reclaim).
You also get an API (and even Zapier for your Asana integration and Motion integration needs). Asana will give you more native out-of-the box integrations with other tools though.
When using both Motion and Asana on-the-go, you're all set with fully featured mobile apps for both (iOS & Android).
So when looking at the key features of both tools, the foundation is there.
The differences between Asana and Motion lie within the teams the tools were created for. Asana is very much for large teams to care about features like project management reporting, dashboards, timeline views, progress reports and more similar features. If these are the features you're interested in, Asana would definitely be a better choice for you.
Motion is better suited for small teams (<50 employees). If you're reading this and thinking "I don't *really* care about reporting dashboards, I just want my team to better manage their projects, be more productive, organized and get work done on time" then Motion would definitely be a better pick for you.
To put things into perspective, after using Asana for 7 years, we switched off to Motion as we found a drastic time-saving component.
Winner: Motion
If you're looking for something new and innovative in the project management space that takes into account more than just the tasks you have in your project manager (e.g. team meetings, workload, team dependencies, time blocking, and more), Motion delivers.
We believe that Motion is actually redefining the entire project management space as a whole, which has otherwise been trending toward the all-in-one category (a vicious trap which brings with it a myriad of problems for which we are overall quite skeptical of).
This is made especially clear when comparing Motion vs Notion, Motion vs ClickUp, and Motion vs Monday. As instead of focusing purely on project management (similar to that of Asana), the rest are getting sidetracked in other categories like team knowledge base and even CRM. 🤦
The task/project management space is due for some innovation, especially with the rise of AI, and only thing we know for sure is that it's not going to happen from the software we just mentioned as they think they've already "won" project management...
That said, we can't help but think that Motion has a genuine shot at actually evolving the space as a whole, as they've been quietly building in the background and have the right team and foundation to completely disrupt what we currently think of when we hear the term "Project Management". If you use Motion, I think you might see the glimpse into the future like we have.
Start your 7 day free trial of Motion here.
Winner: Asana
If you don't care as much about AI or being on the cutting edge, and you value core traditional project management system functionality (e.g. reporting, gantt charts, and a well-refined and stable API), Asana is likely the option as this is where they excel.
It ultimately comes down to what key features you're looking for though. If time blocking or deep calendar integration is important, you're not going to get that with Asana. What you will get though is a deeply integrated and scaleable project management system.
Motion still has a bit more to go on some core functionality (e.g. super robust searching functionality), but that's definitely coming in time but these types of features are readily available in Asana.
In-fact, we personally used Asana in our business for 7 years. It was stable, had a great API (you can even see some of the cool things we've built by integrating Asana using their API), and worked well. While we ultimately made the move to Motion in recent years, that doesn't mean we no longer recommend Asana.
If you're a larger team that highly value stability and traditional project management core features over all else, the truth of the matter is that you can't wrong with Asana. Even when comparing Asana vs ClickUp, Asana vs Monday, Asana vs Notion, you're definitely getting the best project management software when going with Asana as compared to those all-in-one tools.
Start your free trial of Asana here.
Winner: Motion
Your team will enjoy using Motion over Asana as it's so deeply tied to their calendar, and is essentially a daily planner in addition to a project manager, right there within their calendar.
If you're truly looking at it from the individual's standpoint, they can simply live in Motion for their calendar + event scheduling, which in turn will help with adoption, versus jumping between multiple tools (Calendar/Calendly/Asana).
If you're a small to medium team and you can use Motion, we'd recommend it over Asana purely from the enjoyment and ease of use side of things.
Start your 7 day free trial of Motion here.
Winner: Asana
Motion is nowhere near that of Asana when you get outside of the "getting work done" category and move into "upper-management reporting".
If you're a team that's big into goal setting and milestones, while there's ways to visualize it by filtering down views in Motion and leveraging projects for different chunks of a project, you're not going to get the more traditional reporting functionality that upper-management might want.
We'll note that this is nearly irrelevant for the actual teams that are living in the tool on the day-to-day to get work done, so you'd have to ask yourself, is reporting more important for your team than your team actually using a tool and benefiting from it, to help them get work done?
That said if features like project management reporting, dashboards, timeline views, progress reports are core for upper management to see, then Asana would be better suited.
Start your free trial of Asana here.
Winner: Both
While there is a "free" tier to Asana, it's incredibly restrictive feature-wise (just about everything you try to do prompts you to upgrade), and if you have 15+ seats, you'll be forced to the Premium or Business tier. Since this site is more focused on B2B, we're going to discuss the pricing options in a realistic scenario where your company is looking to evaluate Motion vs Asana.
For small teams, Motion and Asana are nearly identical per seat as compared to Asana (paid annual). Not to mention, if you're using Asana long enough, you're going to be pulled to the Business tier—as they gate-keep many features behind it.
You also need to keep in mind the fact that Motion also includes a full calendar (a more powerful layer atop your Google Calendar/Outlook Calendar to view tasks and manage your schedule, and meeting scheduler. So this also replaces the need for most people using Calendly as well, which should free up some budget.
With either tool we recommend starting on the monthly tier for evaluation and within 2–3 months of implementing the tool (whether Motion OR Asana), you should switch to annual for the discount.
It's also a statement you're making to your team that you're committed to making the tool work. We find that larger teams that use a tool month-to-month have a difficult mindset around embracing the tool, as they feel like the company might just switch tools again the following month. Commit to the software and your team will also do the same (plus you get to save nearly 40% on the price by doing so).