Comparison Summary
Comparison SummaryAmie focuses on being an AI note taker without using a meeting bot, while Fantastical is mainly for personal or family calendars and is not suited for professional use.
Only use Fantastical if you need a basic personal calendar, but pick Amie if you want a dedicated AI note taker.
FantasticalFor MacOS + iOS only
For MacOS + iOS only- Amie
Best non-bot AI with audio recording
Best non-bot AI with audio recording
Comparison Video
Comparison VideoBest Calendar Apps
Best Calendar Apps
18:11Best Calendar Apps
Best Calendar AppsRecommended Alternatives
Recommended Alternatives- Superhuman MailRecommended
Best calendar for those already using Superhuman Mail
Best calendar for those already using Superhuman Mail - Sunsama
Best pen and paper alternative
Best pen and paper alternative - MotionRecommended
Best AI calendar that schedules tasks around meetings
Best AI calendar that schedules tasks around meetings
Editor's Verdict
Editor's VerdictAmie has shifted focus away from being a traditional calendar app and now acts mainly as an AI note taker and meeting recorder, with the calendar and to-do features taking a back seat. If what you care about is a modern, effective calendar experience, Amie no longer prioritizes that and isn't built for it anymore.
Fantastical is still a calendar app, but it's described as dated and not recommended even for personal use. For professionals or teams, it's considered far behind other options, lacking the power or modern features expected today.
If you're deciding between these two for calendar use, neither stands out. Amie has basically dropped the ball on calendars, and Fantastical hasn't kept up with newer competitors. If you have to pick only from these two, Fantastical is still technically a calendar app, but you'd be settling for something that's not recommended for personal or professional use. You're better off skipping both and looking elsewhere for anything calendar-related.
